Three small blades compared by what they ask of your hand: grip length, scabbard fit, cast fittings at 60–90 mm, and what a yoroidoshi was built to...
GlobalQuestions
How to Ask an Identification Question (and Get a Real Answer)
Post a blade for identification the right way: the photos and context that get you a real answer, not a guess.

Contents
By Hong Kong Miniature Armor Co. Ltd. · Last updated October 2026
A blade arrives on the bench at 73 cm, and before anyone names it we lay a ruler across it and read the ricasso under a raking light. The measurement is the first fact; the guess is the last thing we offer, and only after the photos and the marks are in the frame.
The photograph below shows the disciplined start. What follows is how we, at the workshop, examine an unknown piece before we would ever put a date to it.

Begin with the whole object, both sides
The single most common failure is a post that shows one glamour shot and nothing else. Start instead with two overall photographs: the complete item, and then the complete item turned over. A sword should be shown flat, blade and hilt in one frame, so the proportions are visible at a glance. The same goes for a helmet, a gauntlet or a lamellar panel — show it whole before you show it close.
Scale is not optional. Lay a ruler, a coin or a marked measuring tape next to the piece, or photograph it in a known hand. A blade that looks “about two feet” in a hand is useless; a blade measured at 73 cm is data. For long objects, a second shot with a tape measure running the full length settles arguments about genre — a short single-edged hanger, a full two-handed longsword, and an officer’s sabre all look similar in a cropped photo and are very different in the hand.
Lighting matters more than camera quality. Shoot in flat, shadowless daylight, not under a single bulb that throws hard glare down the blade. Raking light — a low-angle torch or window — reveals grinding marks, fuller channels, etched decoration and the subtle ripples of a hamon that a front-on flash hides completely. A phone in a bright room beats a “proper” camera in a dark one.

The details that decide the answer
Once the whole object is documented, photograph the features that actually carry information. For a blade, that means the ricasso (the unsharpened section above the guard), any fuller or fullers, and the blade cross-section near the tip — a diamond, a flat lenticular, or a hollow ground profile each point to different traditions and dates. The Oakeshott typology, Ewart Oakeshott’s system for classifying medieval and Renaissance sword blades by their outline and cross-section, is built entirely on these details, and a sharp photo of the forte and the point lets others apply it.
A practical habit is to photograph the object the way a museum catalogue would: outline first, then a labelled set of details, then the mark. Communities such as MyArmoury and the r/ArmouryAndArms subreddit reward posts that already do this, because they let a reader apply a typology without first having to ask for the basic shots. If you can supply the overall length, the blade length, the mass and a clear ricasso, most European blades can be placed within a generation or two by readers who know the typology — which is the whole point of posting in the first place.
The hilt is where many identifications are won or lost. Show the guard (crossguard or basket), the grip wrapping, and the pommel from several angles. Pommel shape — brazil, disk, scent-stopper, fig — and how the grip is bound are period signals that a generic “old sword” description destroys. For a Japanese piece, the tsuba, the same (collar), and the tsuka wrapping are the identifiers; for a South Asian piece, the basket guard and the type of quenching pattern matter most.
Do not forget the back and the underside. A scabbard, a suspension ring, a maker’s plaque, or a regimental stamp often lives where the seller’s hero shot never points. Photograph the scabbard and any fittings separately; a mismatched scabbard is itself a clue that the object may be a later assembly.

Marks, inscriptions and how to read them on camera
Any text on the blade, guard or tang is gold for identification — and it needs its own discipline. Capture every mark as a straight-on, in-focus close-up, then a second shot under raking light so the depth of the cut is visible. Incised marks and etched marks are not the same thing, and a photo that flattens them hides the difference. If the mark is on the tang (the part inside the grip), say so; do not dismantle a valuable piece to photograph it, but note that the mark exists from provenance or a previous examination.
A Japanese signature, the mei, is read from the tang (the nakago) and tells you the smith, the province and often the period — but only when photographed square, with the file marks (yasuri-me) visible, because the geometry of those file marks is itself part of the attribution. A European blade may carry a maker’s mark, an arsenal stamp, a proof mark or a regimental number; each belongs to a different layer of the object’s life and should be listed separately rather than bundled as “some writing.”
One caution worth stating up front: a mark is a lead, not a verdict. Marks have been copied, re-engraved and faked for centuries, and even a genuine mark can sit on a later or altered blade. Photograph it well, transcribe it exactly, and let the community weigh it against documented examples rather than treating it as proof on its own.

The 73 cm blade we photograph before naming
The measurement is the floor. When an unknown blade reaches us we record its overall length first — the 73 cm figure from the guide is a real example — then the blade length, the mass and the ricasso, because those four numbers place most European pieces within a generation once a typology is applied. The arithmetic is trivial but the discipline is not: a blade guessed at 'about two feet' is useless, a blade measured at 73 cm is data, and we will not name a piece we have not measured.
The failure mode is glare. A single overhead bulb throws a hard shine down the blade and hides the fuller, the hamon and the grinding marks that decide the answer, exactly as the guide warns. We shoot under flat daylight or a low-angle torch so the depth of every cut is visible, and we photograph the mark square and raking so an incised mark is not flattened into an etched one. A photo that hides the geometry is worse than no photo.
The judgement call is the unknown. The guide is blunt that a mark is a lead, not a verdict, and we hold the same line: if the tang is inaccessible or no maker's mark exists, we say so rather than invent a date. A confident partial answer is the enemy of a useful one, and we would rather post the negative results — no mark, inaccessible tang — than let a thread build a fiction on a single hero shot. The 73 cm blade is named only after the photos, the marks and the comparable museum pieces all agree.
Where to take the question next
A good database search is a skill of its own. Search by culture and object type before you search by a name you have been told, because the name may be wrong and the type rarely is. Save the three or four closest matches and photograph your piece against them — same angle, same scale — so the community can see the resemblance or the gap directly. The posts that get answered fastest are the ones that already do this comparison and simply ask the thread to confirm or correct it, rather than dumping a single mystery photo and waiting.
The searchable online collections of the Metropolitan Museum’s Arms and Armor department And the Royal Armouries object database Let you set your photos against documented pieces by culture, date and type — often the fastest route from “what is this?” to “this is a type XVIIIb, circa 1450.” The British Museum collection Is the third pillar for ethnographic and early material.
One more discipline: post the negative results too. If you looked for a mark and found none, say so; if the tang was inaccessible, say so. A complete account of what you checked is more useful than a confident partial one, and it stops the thread from inventing details you never saw. The best identification posts read like a short lab note: what was photographed, what was measured, what was absent, and what the comparable museum pieces suggest. When you post, give the community the minimum context that is honest: where the piece came from, what you already know, what you are guessing, and the photos above. State clearly when you do not know the date — a date from a single photograph is a hypothesis, not a fact, and the serious replies will say so. Add your own examples in the comments, and tell us the single photo that once unlocked an identification for you.
A look at genuine historical blades in the Met’s study collection — a reminder of the details, proportions and marks that a careful identification post is trying to capture.
FAQ
What do you measure first on an unknown blade?
Overall length, then blade length, mass and the ricasso. Those four numbers — the 73 cm example is real — let a typology place most European pieces within a generation, and we will not name a blade we have not measured.
Why does lighting matter so much for identification?
Because a single overhead bulb hides the fuller, hamon and grinding marks that decide the answer. Flat daylight or a low-angle torch reveals cut depth; glare flattens an incised mark into an etched one.
How should I photograph a maker's mark at home?
Shoot it square and in focus, then again under raking light so the cut's depth shows. Note if the mark is on the tang and say if it was inaccessible, and transcribe it exactly rather than guessing at a date.
The research and bench team behind miniaturearmor.com. We build 1/6 and 1/12 armour and weapons in our own workshop in Zhuhai — assembly, CNC and 3D printing under one roof — and every piece passes through our hands before it is packed. These notes come from the bench: fit, finish, rust, and the compromises scale forces on a design.
Keep reading in the Miniature Armor Library
- Japanese Armour: Ōyoroi, Dō and Tosei Gusoku
- Collection Stories: What a Collection Says About Its Owner
- Display Setups: Light, Dust and Scale
- New Acquisitions: How to Photograph a Piece Properly
- Myth vs Evidence: 'Damascus Steel' and What Metallurgy Says
Choosing your first piece: start with the Roman Helmets, Japanese Weapons, Chinese Armor & Weapons Or European Armor Collections. For long-term care, our care & maintenance guide Covers cleaning and storage; and if a question needs a human, write to us — the team that answers is the team that packs your order.
Join the Discussion
Have a question, correction, historical reference or collector insight? Join the discussion below.
Please keep discussions respectful, relevant and historically focused. Spam, unrelated promotions and unsafe content may be removed.Community guidelines.
No replies yet
Be the first to add a question, a correction or a collector insight about this topic.